Well, first off I want to thank Allen. As far as my observations can go, I think your information seems right for now.

What's scariest about that is... the Queen not knowing about Catarina and Lillie. Either the Cat hid them from her - or took her memories. And now we don't even have the Queen's word that Catarina and the others were revived after that torturefest. That makes it sound really bad for everyone else in the empty rooms too.

[So this is where it turns more into a question for Manaka...]

Are wishes supposed to be, like, real? Is there any way that the Cat could have just showed up and said she's granting Alice one but actually using some other crazy powers?